Report says bus-bridge plan for ‘Southwest Chief’ would have high cost to local economy NEWSWIRE

Report says bus-bridge plan for ‘Southwest Chief’ would have high cost to local economy NEWSWIRE

By Angela Cotey | January 29, 2019

| Last updated on November 3, 2020


Get a weekly roundup of the industry news you need.

SouthwestChiefStory
Replacing Southwest Chief service over Raton Pass with a bus bridge would have a high price for communities along the route, according to a new report.
Bob Johnston
WASHINGTON — A bus bridge replacing the Southwest Chief between Albuquerque, N.M., and Dodge City, Kan., would lead to annual economic losses of more than $116 million over in the states of Kansas, Colorado, and New Mexico, according to a study commissioned by the Rail Passengers Association.

The study, conducted by researchers from the University of Southern Mississippi with assistance from James Zumwalt, the passenger association’s director of policy research, says those losses stem from cancelled operating spending, fewer visitors and visitor spending, and higher travel costs for families along the route. It also estimated there would be an additional $64 million in losses across the three states in pollution controls, highway fatalities, highway maintenance, and foregone trips. It also says the negative effects would  hit the areas along the Chief route which already are home to the lowest median household income.

“Regular and frequent train service has proved to be an economic engine for communities large and small time and again,” Jim Mathews, president of the Rail Passengers Association, said in a press release accompanying publication of the study. “This study illustrates not only the damage that would have come from Amtrak’s proposed ‘bus bridge’ for the Chief, but also the real ‘return on investment’ for robust rail funding in both urban and rural communities nationwide. … The bus bridge is not a realistic option for Amtrak passengers and surrounding communities. It would create longer travel times and a financial loss for the region. It will be critical for lawmakers to take this study into consideration when developing a surface-transportation bill reauthorization in 2019.”

Amtrak had proposed a bus bridge, either from Alburquerque to Dodge City or Albuquerque to La Junta, Colo, as an alternative to Chief service [see “Raton Pass may lose the ‘Southwest Chief,’ “ Trains News Wire, June 22, 2018], citing concerns over operation without positive train control. The company later backed away from prior statements that it would not operate on routes without PTC [see “Amtrak now aims to continue running all routes …” Trains News Wire, Sept. 17, 2018], ultimately saying it would continue all existing train service at least through the end of fiscal 2019.

The full study, including a detailed look at its methodology, is available here.

Share this article