News & Reviews Creating a model railroaders hall of fame

Creating a model railroaders hall of fame

By Eric White | December 1, 2023

Email Newsletter

Get the newest photos, videos, stories, and more from brands. Sign-up for email today!

Model Railroader is celebrating its 90th anniversary in 2024, so there’s a lot of history there, with all kinds of innovations, great layouts, and amazing products. One thing there hasn’t been is a model railroaders hall of fame.

It’s time to do something about it, so this year, we’re going to nominate people we think should be in a model railroaders hall of fame, and we’re going to ask readers of Model Railroader magazine and members of to weigh in.

Each month, we’ll nominate a few people we think deserve recognition as the inaugural class of the Model Railroaders Hall of Fame, and we’d like you to vote. We’ll also have a comments field so you can tell us why you voted as you have. If you want to make a suggestion for a nominee, please e-mail us at To be eligible, candidates should have made recognizable contributions to the hobby, either as modelers, innovators, manufacturers, communicators, or some combination of those attributes. This will be a posthumous award to ensure the folks recognized are remembered.

We’re starting off with three people who have each had a large impact on the hobby, and given where this is starting, it shouldn’t be a surprise that the first nominee is our founder, Albert C. Kalmbach.

Al Kalmbach

a man in an overcoat waves from the door of a steam locomotive in a black and white image
Al Kalmbach waves from the cab of Milwaukee Road 4-8-4 No. 265. Al was the founder of Kalmbach Media, and in January 1934 he published the first issue of The Model Railroader. The locomotive was on display in Milwaukee, and is now at the Illinois Railway Museum in Union, Ill. A.L Schmidt photo

Al started The Model Railroader in the midst of the Great Depression, sending out his first issue in January 1934. Al was a printer by trade, and was making a living with a print shop in West Allis, Wis., a Milwaukee suburb. Al was also a model railroader, and had a group of friends involved in the hobby. He thought there might be a need for a way for folks to learn about the hobby, so he started his magazine.

Given the times, this was a significant gamble, but it certainly paid off, and it was clear he had found an audience. In 1940, Al would found Trains Magazine just before the United States would find itself embroiled in World War II. Both magazines survived the war, and were perfectly positioned to reap the rewards of a booming postwar economy and population that was looking for diversions in a quickly changing world.

Al used his organizing skills to help get the National Model Railroad Association off the ground, and with Wm. K. Walthers helped form a hotbed of model railroading in the Milwaukee area. Al would helm Kalmbach Publishing Co. (now Kalmbach Media) until his death in 1981. It’s safe the say the hobby would have been much different without the company he founded, which leads us to the next nominee.

Linn Westcott

A man strings masking tape between supports while standing in the midst of model railroad benchwork in this black and white image
Linn Westcott creates a web of masking tape in order to build hard-shell scenery, one of many concepts he either created or popularized that have become integral to the hobby. Below the wooden joists, you can see his L-girders. Linn Westcott photo

Linn Westcott was the editor of Model Railroader from 1961 to 1977, and while he held that position, and even before, he found the time to offer many innovations to the hobby. People still build their layouts using Linn’s L-girder benchwork, made by adding a 1×2 or 1×3 flange to a 1×4 or 1×6 plate to create an inverted L-shaped beam that’s light, cheap, and strong. Hard-shell scenery, where paper or cloth is dipped in soupy plaster and draped over a form of wadded newspaper and masking tape, is another innovation that remains with us today, albeit with updates such as plaster-impregnated gauze and woven cardboard forms.

Linn was also interested in electronics. He created some of the first transistorized direct-current throttles, as well as detection circuits to trigger signals, and momentum features for DC throttles. Linn joined the staff of Model Railroader during its first year of publication as a draftsman, with his name appearing on the masthead in September 1934. Earlier that year, he had an article on building an automatic pantograph, complete with cutaway drawings. Linn was also know for his photography, appearing in articles about various model railroading subjects, and is also known as an accomplished railfan photographer.

W. Allen McLelland

A man in a white shirt stands in the midst of an Appalachian scene on a model railroad
Allen McClelland was another innovator. He developed walkaround throttles so he could follow the trains on his freelanced Virginian & Ohio, which was designed to represent a part of the national rail network. W. Allen McClelland photo

Our third nominee, Allen McClelland, is best known as the builder of the freelanced Virginian & Ohio HO scale model railroad. The part that made the V&O more than just a model railroad was the way Allen wanted to make it a believable transportation system.

Allen’s railroads (he built more than one part of the imaginary V&O) didn’t run in a circle. They started at one place and went to another. The track didn’t circle over itself, the main line only appeared once in each scene. At the end of the railroad, the main line disappeared out of view and went to a staging yard, where trains could wait for their next appearance “on stage.” The layout was built with a linear design so the operator could follow his train around the layout. This meant Allen had to design a control system operators could carry with them, and walkaround Digital Command Control throttles didn’t exist in the 1960s.

Allen saw what model railroading could be, and moved to make his vision happen. Neary everything that has come since in layout design can be traced back to Allen and his Virginian & Ohio. Allen was important enough we published a book about him. Certainly, he’s someone who deserves to be recognized!


You can vote for the January candidates here.

4 thoughts on “Creating a model railroaders hall of fame

  1. I want to nominate Whit Towers. He was instrumental for incorporating operations into his layout designs, such as his Alturs Yard which, I have a modified version of on my layout

    Please make it easier to click on a link to find the voting box. It is not evidently found, had to look around then use search to find it.

    Skip Caswell

  2. Great idea and, indeed, long overdue! But how will it work? I mean all three are no-brainer “first ballot hall of famers”, so if we can only vote for one then will the other two stay on the “ballot” for the next month?

  3. I want to be sure you include Frank Ellison in your nominations. At one time, a great leader in both scenicked layouts and in realistic operation. MR published a seminal 6-part series in 1944 and reprinted it in 1964-65. His Delta Liines was certainly legendary in its day.
    Probably the best-known model railroader following Ellison was John Allen, and again, I am sure you intend to nominate him. Linn Westcott’s excellent book about John showed both his remarkable layout and also mentions his devotion of realistic operation.
    Third, I want to mention someone perhaps not so obvious. Doug Smith was the inventor of the original car-card system for freight car operation, later modified by Allen McClelland, and the direct ancestor of today’s familiar 4-part waybill. Doug’s superb article in MR, really a review article, was a landmark even when new, and is still read for its ideas (December 1961).
    Tony Thompson

You must login to submit a comment