Railroads & Locomotives Fallen Flags New Haven Railroad history

New Haven Railroad history

By J.W. Swanberg | August 26, 2021

The New York, New Haven & Hartford is Classic Trains’ Railroad of the Month for September 2021

Email Newsletter

Get the newest photos, videos, stories, and more from Trains.com brands. Sign-up for email today!

Overhead color photo of two streamlined diesel locomotives departing station with passenger train
The original “McGinnis scheme,” resuscitated later on Connecticut DOT units, is fresh on FL9s 2044 and 2002 as they leave New Haven for New York on May 22, 1962. In the engine servicing area are more FL9s and an Alco PA. A melodious Hancock air whistle is between 2044’s windshields. J.W. Swanberg

History of the New Haven Railroad

New Haven Railroad history reveals that the New York, New Haven & Hartford was a railroad of many different faces, depending on which part you saw.

The double-track Shore Line between New Haven and Boston was home to famous trains such as the Merchants Limited and Yankee Clipper, hauled by streamlined I-5 Hudsons or members of the largest fleet of Alco DL109 diesels, or the later Alco PAs and Fairbanks-Morse C-Liners. The four-track, electrified “West End” between New Haven and New York City was filled with intercity name trains and much suburban-zone M.U.-car activity. The New Haven shared Grand Central Terminal with the New York Central, but the intercity trains to and from south of New York used Pennsylvania Railroad’s Penn Station by way of the giant Hell Gate Bridge.

New Haven’s freight artery across Connecticut and New York State to the Maybrook (N.Y.) gateway was heavy­duty “mountain” railroading, with big L-1 2-10-2s pulling and pushing long drags across a sawtooth profile. They would be succeeded by matched sets of Alco FAs, and finally by almost any mix of freight diesel power imaginable (including borrowed off-line units).

The great glass and steel trainshed at Boston’s South Station saw the largest concentration of passenger traffic in the U.S. in the early 1900s, including the famous Fall River Boat Train which met palatial New Haven-owned steamships to and from New York for 90 years. New Haven’s interurban-like early D.C. electric operations featured open cars and closed cars carrying the multitudes to Nantasket Beach, Mass., Providence, R.I., or New Britain, Conn. Further, New Haven railroaders were at the helm of numerous steam and diesel tugs in New York Harbor, delivering car floats to connections west of the Hudson River. Scenic country branch lines were another face of the New Haven, including trains through the Berkshire Hills to Pittsfield, Mass., which boasted parlor cars into the 1960s.

Black-and-white map of New Haven Railroad
A map from the 1940s shows how the New Haven’s compact system blanketed southern New England.

New Haven Railroad history: Formed by merger in 1872

The New York, New Haven & Hartford Railroad was formed in 1872 by the merger of the Hartford & New Haven and the New York & New Haven. The fledgling NYNH&H owned just 85 locomotives and was surrounded by competitors, both rail and water. Under the 1887–99 reign of its most able president, Charles Peter Clark, the New Haven mushroomed in size and profitability by taking over railroads large and small. One was the fabled Old Colony, which secured the final Providence–Boston link of NH’s Shore Line route from New York. Meanwhile its most dangerous threat, the partly parallel New York & New England, was absorbed by 1898, giving the New Haven an almost-total rail monopoly in southern New England.

The New Haven was a financial powerhouse at the start of the 20th century, but from 1903 to 1913, the road was driven to near bankruptcy under President Charles S. Mellen and financier J. P. Morgan. One gain in this period, though, was control of the Central New England Railway, which included the Hudson River bridge at Poughkeepsie, N.Y., and the link to Maybrook and nearby Campbell Hall. This was New Haven’s gateway to the west, also served by trunk lines Erie; New York, Ontario & Western; and bridge lines Lehigh & Hudson River and Lehigh & New England.

World War I government control and the Roaring 1920s boom times saved the New Haven, but not enough to survive the Great Depression, and bankruptcy came in 1935. World War II traffic allowed recovery and rebuilding, but soon all was lost by mismanagement and bankruptcy came again in 1961. The postwar New Haven faced not only highway and airline competition but also the almost total erosion of New England’s heavy industrial base. Just a shell of the once-mighty railroad was forced into a reluctant Penn Central on Jan. 1, 1969.

Low-angle black-and-white photo of 4-8-2 steam locomotive making smoke with freight train
Seldom-photographed New Haven three-cylinder R-3-a 4-8-2 3562 storms through Warehouse Point, Conn., with symbol freight SN-5 in March 1947.
Robert A. Whitbeck

New Haven steam locomotives

Throughout its history, the New Haven ran a variety of equipment, both rail and non-rail. Its early steam power was mostly 4-4-0s for its heavy passenger traffic, but acquisition of so many other railroads resulted in a roster potpourri, from low-wheeled, Belpaire-boilered 2-8-0s built for NY&NE drag freights to exotic double-ended Old Colony Mason “Bogie” 2-4-6Ts that would have looked at home on the Denver, South Park & Pacific.

Until the Morgan-Mellen regime’s cost cutting resulted in shoddy power, New Haven locomotives were customarily spit-shined, with gold leaf and polished brasswork. Meanwhile, early Pacifics and high-drivered Atlantics of 1907 were supplemented by heavier power, culminating in 50 class I-4 4-6-2s of 1916. Ahead of their time in design, they pulled the road’s best trains for more than two decades until the Hudsons arrived. Freight steam power ranged U.S. Railroad Administration 0-8-0s and 4-8-2s to three-cylinder 4-8-2s with water-tube fireboxes.

Color photo of box-cab electric locomotive with passenger train on curve beside river
On the old Danbury & Norwalk, EP-2 electric 325 leaves Wilton, Conn., on a 1954 summer Sunday with train 139, the Mahkeenac, from Pittsfield, Mass.
Thomas J. McNamara

New Haven electrification and electric locomotives

The New Haven’s 1907 electrification from its New York Central connection at Woodlawn, N.Y., to Stamford, Conn., was a bold, risky, pioneering commitment to 11,000-volt A.C. catenary, which required the use of dual-voltage locomotives to operate on NYC’s conventional 650-volt D.C. third rail from Woodlawn into Grand Central. New Haven passenger electrics had to change at speed between the two systems, raising or lowering pantographs and third-rail shoes as required, a daunting technical challenge for the time.

Eventually 673 New Haven track-miles were under wire, including all electric-zone freight and switching. A succession of electric locomotive types culminated in the EP-5 rectifier passenger motors of 1955.

New Haven diesel locomotives

A diesel pioneer from its first Alco switcher of 1931 to its 1952 elimination of steam, the New Haven stayed with Alco right up through 10 C425s of 1964. NH also had diesels from Lima­Hamilton, Fairbanks-Morse, GE-Ingersoll-Rand, and General Electric, the latter ranging from early 44-tonners to latter-day U25Bs. New Haven had no EMD locomotives, though, until SW1200s and GP9s arrived in 1956.

Perhaps NH’s most famous latter-day locomotives were its 60 dual­power (diesel- and third­rail-electric) FL9s, the last of which was EMDs final F unit, built in 1960. Gas-electrics, Budd RDCs, and unsuccessful low-slung lightweight trains added variety. Innumerable paint schemes, including many versions of the flashy red­white-and-black introduced in 1955 during the brief tenure of controversial President Patrick B. McGinnis, assured that NH’s locomotive fleet would never be all in the same livery.

Detailed information about the New Haven for historians and model railroaders is available from the New Haven Railroad Historical & Technical Association.

4 thoughts on “New Haven Railroad history

  1. I grew up in Bay Ridge Bklyn. and i use to watch the E33,s & E44,s running in and out of Busch Terminal and the the car float terminal , the tracks ran by 60th thru 65st and their were 2-3 tracks which ran to the Hells Gate Bridge . You could hear the humming of the Electric E33&44,s Engines coming for blocks and I would run to the overpass the watch these trains and I use to wave to the engineers and they would blow the horn , what memories . To bad the yard is only a small percentage of what it use to be , surprised CSX or Norfolk & Southern don,t try to use this connection !

  2. Greg Scholl has a superb DVD for sale of 1950’s New Haven railroading. The sharp, excellent color footage was done by a former U.S. Navy photographer and is rock-steady. You’ll enjoy branch line excursion on sparkling Budd RDC’s and a lot of Hunter Green, Alco FA-powered freight on the Maybrook line along with a lot of passenger train scenes.

  3. I’m a huge FL9 fan. Elegant solution for the time. I had a few years of riding LIRR trains on the Port Jeff line that were fronted and backed by FL9AC’s – beautifully rebuilt NH FL9’s that looked and sounded great, but which had reliability problems in 2 areas I’m aware of. The early computerization, and the apparently easily overheated inverters. LIRR had 3 locos, and instead of doing the obvious, having one as a spare, used it as a parts source. This completely defeated the purpose of having dual mode locos since the train needed 2 to safely operate in and out of Penn. I was told by multiple sources back then that maintenance was beyond poor, and that also included the bi level cars. The train had a nickname – the Bitanic.

    When the Super Steel dual mode junk went into service, the Bitanic went out of service. Cars were sold off, and it’s my understanding that for no apparent reason the FL9AC’s were scrapped, even though they could normally run well on diesel power.

  4. Not many people today realize that the NH had a leading “0” (zero) on electric and diesel locomotive for many years. At some point, someone can tell me when, the leading 0 was painted over. I have seen photos of the painted out 0 peeking out through the paint.

    Ed Burns, Retired Class 1

You must login to submit a comment