OTTAWA — A 2018 derailment of a train near the Manitoba-Ontario border was caused by a cracked wheel with a previously detected fault which did not meet U.S. safety guidelines, but did not require immediate action under Canadian National Railway rules.
The Transportation Safety Board of Canada’s summary of a report on the Jan. 6, 2018, derailment near Rennie, Man., issued Wednesday, says the accident “highlights the need for additional means to proactively identify emerging sub-surface cracks in wheels and remove them from service prior to failure.”
That accident derailed 23 cars, eight of them carrying “ an accident that derailed 23 cars, eight of them “carrying dangerous goods,” according to the report. No leak occured and no one was injured.
The accident was caused by a rim fracture on a wheel on the 38th car of the 64-car train. In the two days prior to the accident, lineside detectors had recorded five wheel impacts for that car (because of an out-of-round wheel) in excess of Association of American Railroad rules, which recommend removal of wheels registering impacts of 90,000 pounds, or 90 kilopounds (kip), or above. CN’s own guidelines, however, considers impacts up to 139 kip to be subject to “opportunistic repairs,” the TSB report says, meaning at the next opportunity at a certificed car inspection location.
The TSB’s summary says the investigation shows a need for additional enhancements for cracked-wheel detection and a need for ultrasonic testing after wheel reprofiling.
The full report is available here.
Well we’d assume some logic would prevail here and CN would lower impact ratings down to the AAR measurements
Hey, Michael Klass! Although a cracked wheel/broken axle has not been a direct culprit of a BNSF crude oil train derailment, don’t forget that it was an indirect culprit in one such case at Casselton, ND when a BNSF grain train derailed in front of a loaded crude oil train due to a broken axle on one of the grain cars.
Here’s a link to a video. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZhraoVIJ1OE
Michael, Your translation skills are good. I see this all the time on our BNSF crude trains. Luckily, it has not yet resulted in an accident.
From my experience in non-rail industries “opportunistic repairs” means “Let the next guy take care of it.”